---
title: "Four changes to how we score: what moved on 21 October and why"
description: Verification and NIST alignment now judge only the signatures that protect funds, two tiers are reworded and forks inherit measured exposure.
url: "https://hardyindex.com/news/methodology-v1-8-verification-nist-exposure"
section: What changed
type: index-change
published: 2026-10-21
updated: 2026-10-21
chains: iota, bitcoin-cash, solana, monero, qrl, nervos-ckb
methodology_version: 1.8
---

# Four changes to how we score: what moved on 21 October and why

**Methodology v1.8 took effect on 21 October 2026. Verification and NIST alignment now judge only the post-quantum component that protects a chain's funds, so open classical code and identity-layer schemes stop earning points. Two tiers are reworded and no chain changes tier. A fork inherits the measured exposure of its shared history. IOTA moved most.**

*Published 21 October 2026. The rating below is current as of 17 November 2026. This is a security-readiness assessment, not investment advice.*

Readers who checked our working found places where the rubric credited the wrong thing. These are the fixes.

## Why the rules are changing

The point of publishing every anchor and every placement is that a reader can check our working. Readers did, and they found four places where the rubric, applied exactly as written, credited something other than what it claims to measure. None of them was an arithmetic error: every score reproduced from its six dimensions. The problem was what the dimensions were counting.

Three of the four fixes lower scores. They took effect on 21 October, the day they were published, and every number on the site is now calculated the new way. The [v1.8 page](https://hardyindex.com/methodology/v1-8) sets out the old and new wording side by side, and lists every chain's score and rank before and after, including the chains that did not move.

## Verification will judge the post-quantum part, not the rest

The complaint: verification was effectively inverted. It was meant to ask whether a chain's post-quantum claims are backed by open code, audits and review. In practice it scored open-source pedigree, so Monero, which has no post-quantum component at all, scored higher than Abelian, which has run post-quantum signatures on mainnet since 2022.

The fix: the dimension now reads only the post-quantum component protecting funds. A chain with none sits in the bottom band however open its classical code is. Above that, the bands step up from a component that exists but nobody outside its authors has reviewed, to one with outside review or a named audit, to one that is audited and checkable on mainnet. Review by the team that wrote the code does not count, and neither does review of a library it calls.

That reading is strict, and it lands on some of the chains furthest ahead. NEAR's and Algorand's post-quantum accounts are live and checkable on mainnet, but we found no review of either integration beyond their own maintainers, so both sit at the top of the unreviewed band. Nervos CKB moves up, because its component has been independently audited and runs on mainnet. QRL's audits were recorded as a correction the same day, so it did not move again. The same reading puts Zcash in the bottom band: its quantum-recoverability mechanism prepares notes for a recovery protocol that has not yet been specified, which is preparation rather than a post-quantum component. At a 5% weight no chain moves more than three and a half points on this dimension alone.

## NIST alignment will count only schemes that protect coins

The complaint: IOTA scored for ML-DSA, SLH-DSA and Falcon in IOTA Identity, which secures credentials rather than coins, and that was the main reason an Exposed chain ranked above Bitcoin.

The fix: the dimension now scores only schemes a chain has deployed, tested or proposed for its own fund-protecting signatures, including the validator signatures that finalise them. We considered going further and crediting only schemes on a dated plan, and decided against it: that would also have moved Bitcoin and Monero, whose research names NIST schemes as candidates, and the existing middle band is written for exactly that case. As worded, this moved IOTA alone, and IOTA falls back below Bitcoin.

## A fork will inherit the measured exposure of its shared history

The complaint: Bitcoin Cash scored far better than Bitcoin on exposure, although it carries every output Bitcoin had before August 2017, including the early pay-to-public-key coins whose keys have always been on-chain. The measurements were done on Bitcoin, so being measured was punished and being unmeasured was rewarded.

The fix is a general rule rather than a Bitcoin Cash adjustment: where a chain shares another chain's history, the published measurements of that history apply to it until a measurement of its own exists. Today it applies to Bitcoin Cash, which dropped four points and stays in Shipping.

## Two tiers say what they test, and nobody moved

The complaints: Solana sat in Shipping against the letter of that rung, which also asked for a migration to be underway, and the Committed rung asked for public dates that four of its chains do not have.

- Shipping now asks only for a post-quantum signature live on mainnet that ordinary holders can use. Migration is scored on its own dimension, so the rung was counting it twice. Solana's placement now fits the definition, so its caveat about migration goes. A narrower judgement call stays: its post-quantum wallet is reached through a command-line tool, and a reader who requires wallet support would place it a rung lower.
- Committed now asks for a plan from the chain's own authority, naming a post-quantum scheme or a funded programme to select one. Dates belong to the commitments tracker. Requiring them here would have demoted chains for a missing tracker entry rather than a missing plan.
- A draft proposal is not a plan, so Tron stays in Debating: its TIP-899 is still a draft.

## If you think a score is wrong

Corrections of fact carry on as normal and take effect as soon as they are confirmed. The changelog records every chain's score either side of v1.8, and anyone watching a chain that moved is told.

> **Corrections.** Send the primary source through the [contact form](https://hardyindex.com/contact) as a correction. A chain's own submission is treated like anyone else's.

## Where to go next

- [IOTA: the full rating](https://hardyindex.com/chains/iota.md): every dimension score, with the source behind each one.
- [Bitcoin Cash: the full rating](https://hardyindex.com/chains/bitcoin-cash.md): every dimension score, with the source behind each one.
- [Solana: the full rating](https://hardyindex.com/chains/solana.md): every dimension score, with the source behind each one.
- [Monero: the full rating](https://hardyindex.com/chains/monero.md): every dimension score, with the source behind each one.
- [Quantum Resistant Ledger: the full rating](https://hardyindex.com/chains/qrl.md): every dimension score, with the source behind each one.
- [Nervos CKB: the full rating](https://hardyindex.com/chains/nervos-ckb.md): every dimension score, with the source behind each one.
- [Which is the most quantum-resistant blockchain?](https://hardyindex.com/guides/most-quantum-resistant-blockchain.md): One question, one answer, with the working shown. This page is a summary of the Hardy Index, which is the live ranking behind it.
- [Which crypto is quantum proof?](https://hardyindex.com/guides/which-crypto-is-quantum-proof.md): Plenty of projects call themselves quantum proof. Here is the independently checked version, and why the phrase itself is worth handling carefully.
- [Every chain, before and after](https://hardyindex.com/methodology/v1-8): The v1.8 page, with the old and new wording side by side.
- [The rubric in force today](https://hardyindex.com/methodology): Every anchor of the rubric in force.

## Sources

Every dated event above carries its own primary source. These are those sources, checked on the dates shown.

1. [Methodology v1.8: what changed](https://hardyindex.com/methodology/v1-8): The Hardy Index (primary, checked 21 October 2026)
2. [Post-Quantum Cryptography: IOTA Identity](https://docs.iota.org/developer/iota-identity/how-tos/post-quantum): IOTA Foundation (primary, checked 21 October 2026)
3. [Measuring Bitcoin's quantum-exposed supply](https://research.glassnode.com/measuring-bitcoins-quantum-exposed-supply/): Glassnode (primary, checked 21 October 2026)
4. [Quantum-resistant lock script audit report](https://scalebit.xyz/reports/20251216-Quantum-Resistant-Lock-Script-Final-Audit-Report.pdf): ScaleBit (primary, checked 21 October 2026)
5. [QRL security audits](https://github.com/theQRL/audits): The QRL Contributors on GitHub (primary, checked 21 October 2026)

---
Cite as: The Hardy Index, "Four changes to how we score: what moved on 21 October and why", https://hardyindex.com/news/methodology-v1-8-verification-nist-exposure, published 21 October 2026.
